Dating Over 50 Red Flags: Is It a Problem If He Says You Wear Too Much Makeup?

A New Series: Real Talk About Dating Over 50

If you’ve been here for a while, you know I talk a lot about style, beauty, and confidence. However, one topic that consistently sparks conversation — and fills my DMs — is dating. So I’ve decided it’s time to create a space for those conversations here on the blog. Each week, we’re going to talk honestly about dating over 50 — the good, the confusing, and yes, the red flags. Because many of us are navigating this season again, and we deserve clarity and confidence as we do it.

Today’s question is such a good one so keep scrolling to join the conversation!

AQUA DRESS (XS)  // SILVER HEELS // HANDBAG

The Question That Landed in My DMs

Dating over 50 red flags are rarely dramatic at first. They usually don’t show up in obvious ways. Instead, they often come disguised as small comments or subtle suggestions that leave you wondering how to feel. A woman recently messaged me and said she had been dating a man for a while when he told her he thought she wore too much makeup. She asked me if that was a red flag.

I definitely have thoughts on this — and they’re based on experience.

Now, you all know I love makeup. I enjoy the creativity of it, and I love feeling polished and put together. At the same time, I also have plenty of days without it. I go to yoga. I work out. I run errands bare-faced. So when I hear a comment like that, I don’t immediately think about mascara or foundation. I think about the intention behind the words.

Healthy vs. Unhealthy: There’s a Big Difference

Years ago, the most unhealthy man I was ever with told me he wished I would wear less makeup because he thought I wore too much. On the surface, that might not sound like a big deal. However, the tone felt different. It didn’t feel like admiration or appreciation. It felt like correction. It felt like he was subtly trying to shape me into something that made him more comfortable. And that feeling stayed with me.

In contrast, the healthiest man I’ve dated once told me I looked beautiful without makeup. Naturally, I asked him if that meant he preferred that I not wear it. His response was simple — I looked beautiful either way. There was no pressure in his voice, no underlying request, no need for me to change anything. It was simply appreciation.

And that difference matters.

It’s Not About Makeup — It’s About Control

When we’re talking about dating over 50 red flags, it’s important to look beyond the surface issue. This isn’t really about makeup. It’s about autonomy. It’s about whether someone feels secure enough to let you be fully yourself. A healthy partner doesn’t need to edit you in order to feel confident. He doesn’t need to diminish something you enjoy to feel comfortable in the relationship. Instead, he appreciates you — dressed up for dinner or fresh-faced after yoga.

At this stage of life, that distinction becomes even more important. We have done the work. We know who we are. So if a comment makes you feel smaller instead of supported, it’s worth paying attention to. That’s often how dating over 50 red flags quietly reveal themselves.

Personally, I don’t believe it’s healthy for a man to tell a woman how much makeup she should or shouldn’t wear. Of course, everyone has preferences, and there’s nothing wrong with expressing admiration. However, there is a clear line between appreciation and control. The right man will feel secure enough to let you choose how you present yourself, because his confidence won’t depend on changing you.

I Want to Hear From You!

I would truly love to hear your thoughts on this. Has a man ever commented on your makeup? Did it feel supportive, or did it feel like subtle criticism? Do you consider this a red flag? These conversations are important, and they help all of us navigate dating over 50 with more clarity and confidence.

Outfit of the Night

And because I know you’ll ask — this beautiful blue dress I’m wearing is under $100, comes with a slip, and is incredibly comfortable. I love how flattering and easy it is, which is why I own it in three different colors. It’s one of those pieces that feels effortless but still polished, whether you’re heading out on a date or meeting friends for dinner. I’ve linked it here for you.

FEEL FREE TO SUBSCRIBE TO MY  YOUTUBE CHANNEL FOR STYLE, BEAUTY, AND FITNESS TIPS TO HELP WOMEN LOOK AND FEEL CONFIDENT

CHECK OUT MY INSTAGRAM SHOP TO SHOP ALL OF MY INSTAGRAM LOOKS

YOU CAN ALSO DOWNLOAD THE LIKETOKNOW.IT APP AND FOLLOW ME ON IT BY CLICKING HERE.

STAY IN THE KNOW:  SUBSCRIBE to receive exclusive sale alerts, life-changing style tips, and fabulous giveaways, AND GET ACCESS TO MY VIP WARDROBE ESSENTIAL VIDEO ONLY FOR SUBSCRIBERS! 

Thank you so much for stopping by today, I truly appreciate you!